That's odd. Those should be the settings. You could also turn off 'receive site mailings' here: http://warioforums.com/index.php?account/privacy And see if that does anything?
Thanks for getting back to me. I've unchecked the mailing option there, I'll let you know if it worked!
http://warioforums.com/index.php?account/privacy
And see if that does anything?